CLA-2 CO:R:CV:G: 085424 JLV; 843926 NY
Ms. Connie Kallenbach
3067 Unionville Pike
Hatfield, PA 19440
RE: Formatic 4 tractor with power-driven trailer; track-
laying motor vehicle and trailer
Dear Ms. Kallenbach:
In a letter of July 27, 1989, you requested a ruling on
the tariff classification of a track-laying motor vehicle and
power-driven trailer which will be imported together. Your
request was in response to a ruling letter of May 31, 1989
(file 840723), in which the Formatic 2 was classified in
subheading 8701.30.5015, Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the
United States Annotated (HTSUSA), but additional information
was requested on the Formatic 4 and trailer.
FACTS:
The Formatic 4 base unit is identical in size and engine
to the Formatic 2, and is similarly described as an all-
terrain motor vehicle that can be used to transport persons
and goods and to push or pull equipment. The distinguishing
feature is the additional coupling designed to permit the use
of a powered trailer with the base unit. When the Formatic 4
is coupled with the specially-designed powered trailer, the
steering is changed from a skid-steer system to an articulated
steering (body steer) controlled by hydraulic cylinders at the
coupling. In order to accommodate the powered trailer, the
Formatic 4 must have a hydraulic connection to supply fluid to
the two hydraulic motors in the trailer. Both the Formatic 4
and the powered trailer are track-laying vehicles, i.e.,
mounted on tracks rather than on wheels.
The trailer, fitted with the standard cargo bed, has a
loading area of 1600 mm by 2400 mm amd a load capacity of 1800
kg. With the standard cargo bed, it is designed with
mountings for various accessories and machines, such as a
- 2 -
crane, hydraulic support legs and log holders, and protection
gratings. The trailer frame can also be fitted with a
passenger cabin for 10 persons. The passenger cabin and the
standard cargo bed are options which can be relatively easily
attached to the powered trailer frame.
The trailer, although described as "powered" and designed
with two hydraulic motors to provide tractive power to the
tracks, is not self-propelled. The trailer does not have its
own power source (motor and hydraulic pump to power the two
hydraulic motors). The two hydraulic motors can become
functional only when the trailer is coupled to the Formatic 4
tractor and its hydraulic system. Furthermore, the trailer
has no independent steering system.
The two hydraulic motors can be disengaged and the
trailer towed in free wheel when the additional traction is
not required. Although the trailer can be towed in free
wheel, it cannot be safely used as trailer by any other type
of vehicle because of the unique coupling device.
The Formatic 4 and powered trailer are produced in
Finland.
ISSUE:
What is the classification of the Formatic 4 and the
powered trailer, if imported together? If classified
separately, is the powered trailer "mechanically propelled"
within the meaning of heading 8716?
LAW AND ANALYSIS:
In a ruling of May 31, 1989 (file 840723), the Formatic 2
all-terrain vehicle was classified under the provision for
other track-laying tractors in subheading 8701.30.50, HTSUSA.
This ruling controls the classification of the Formatic 4 base
unit which is substantially the same in design and, because of
this design, falls under note 2, chapter 87, HTSUSA. Although
the rear deck of the Formatic 4 has a cargo-carrying function,
it is subsidiary to the basic vehicle design, which is to push
or pull equipment, such as a snowblade, snow tiller, ski track
machine, front loader, bush and grass cutter, and trailer.
The Explanatory Notes (EN) to heading 87.01 are
instructive on the classification of tractors fitted with
other machinery. Interchangeable working tools, even when
fitted to tractors, remain classified in their appropriate
- 3 -
headings. In this case, the Formatic 4 tractor will be
imported with a trailer. The powered trailer is a specialized
accessory for the tractor. It is powered by the hydraulic
system of the tractor. The trailer is designed for accepting
various tools and equipment, such as a passenger module, cargo
bed, sky lift, rotator and grapple, drill, excavator shovel,
and special cargo attachments (support legs, log holders,
protection gratings), all of which can be attached or removed
relatively easily. The trailer requires a special coupling
that is built into the Formatic 4, and it cannot be used or
towed by another vehicle.
The powered trailer is not a "semi-trailer" as the term
is commonly used, because the trailer is not supported in part
by the tractor. However, the trailer remains separately
classified because the trailer functions as an accessory to
the tractor. The Formatic 4 tractor is fully functional
without the powered trailer. The powered trailer, as an
accessory device for use with the tractor, provides a
versatile trailer for transporting articles, for supporting
various tools and equipment, or for personnel transport.
Heading 8716 covers trailers and semi-trailers, and other
vehicles, not mechanically propelled [emphasis added]. The
trailer, in this case, has the same type of hydraulic motors
as does the tractor. The trailer, however, is not self-
propelled because it has no self-contained power source or
steering mechanism. The question, therefore, is whether the
powered trailer is mechanically propelled within the meaning
of heading 8716.
The term "mechanically propelled" is not synonymous with
"self-propelled." For example, wheelchairs with a mechanical
device for propulsion when operated by the physical action of
the operator are not self-propelled. They are, however,
mechanically propelled. In this case, the hydraulic motors,
powered by a pump located on a tractor, provide mechanical
propulsion to the tracks on the trailer. Furthermore, the
means by which it is "steered," i.e., towed by a tractor, does
not make the trailer any less "mechanically propelled" by the
two hydraulic motors. Heading 8716 covers trailers, semi-
trailers, and other vehicles, not mechanically propelled.
Therefore, the powered trailer for the Formatic 4 is precluded
from classification in heading 8716.
By its design, the powered trailer is principally or
solely used with the Formatic 4 tractor. Absent a more
specific provision for this type of mechanically propelled
- 4 -
trailer, it is classifiable as an accessory for a tractor of
heading 8701 in heading 8708, HTSUSA. Note 3, section XVII,
HTSUSA.
HOLDING:
The Formatic 4 tractor base is classified as a track-
laying tractor, other, in subheading 8701.30.50, HTSUSA,
dutiable at 2.2 percent ad valorem. The powered trailer is
classified as an other accessory of a motor vehicle of heading
8701, other, in subheading 8708.99.50, HTSUS, dutiable at 3.1
percent ad valorem.
Sincerely,
John Durant, Director
Commercial Rulings Division
6cc: AD NY Seaport
2cc: Chief, CIE
1cc: NIS O'Connell (106)
1cc: AC, CO
1cc: Reading File
1cc: Durant
LIBRARY: valentine
FILE NAME: 085424